Request details

Display online comments in desktop application

It's great to have add and see comments in the online prototype. But even better (for the designer) would be to see those comments *in the design file.*

I envision a third tab next to Design and Prototype: Comments (or Feedback). When you go to that tab, you see all your artboards, but you also see any comments that have been made on the online prototype. Pin or bubble icons (or whatever) appear next to artboards with comments, which you can click to pull up the comments in a comments panel (similar to the layers and symbols panels, but perhaps on the right side of the screen). In that panel, you can navigate your comments for that artboard, reply, resolve, etc.). Ideally, you could zoom out in this panel to see a list of all your comments (as you can zoom out to see a list of all your artboards in the layers panel). What's helpful about that is when you only have a few comments left, you can easily find them without having to zoom out on your pasteboard to find them visually.

But comments are only online, you say! How would they get into the file? Wouldn't it be great if every time you click Update Link, not only did it upload any updates to CC, but it downloaded any comments that have been made?! Right?! And when you resolve comments or reply, clicking Update Link sends the updates up to CC. Naturally, the wording and UI would need to be changed to reflect more of a *syncing* functionality rather than just updating a link.

Why would this be so valuable? The entire value proposition of Adobe XD is that we designers don't have to go back and forth between two or more platforms, but could do everything in XD. This would allow that vision to be real. Otherwise, we still have to toggle between XD and a browser window. But if all comments could be downloaded into the file, we could see comments on our designs and change them *right there and then!!!* That, my friends, would be amazing.

114 votes
Sign in
(thinking…)
Sign in with: facebook google
Signed in as (Sign out)

We’ll send you updates on this idea

David Knell shared this idea  ·   ·  Flag idea as inappropriate…  ·  Admin →

16 comments

Sign in
(thinking…)
Sign in with: facebook google
Signed in as (Sign out)
Submitting...
  • Anonymous commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    Very nice post, I visited your blog for the first time and became your fan. best health tips

  • Anonymous commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    It has very important things in it which will give the best facts to read excellent work.

  • Zachary Newton commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    I agree. I think it would be very beneficial to at least see the pinned comments within the actual application when working on screens. Would be awesome to see all of the comments whether pinned or not when clicking on an artboard.

  • Denis Teleshevskii commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    Now I can see my prototypes comments only in browser via shared links. It's weird and hard to work with. I really need to work with the comments thru Adobe XD application during design.

  • Harun Alikadić commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    Maybe something more similar to Google Docs commenting. Not a separate "view" like in Invision but continuous presence (in design view, prototype, web, specs).
    Another feature could be making the comments private, these are designer's notes.

  • Derek Watson commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    This would be an excellent addition and speed up workflow if comments are visible whist editing page

  • Cameron Sagey commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    This would be amazing. Check out how Figma does it, that's the one feature that tempts me to use Figma.

    What would make it even better is having a dedicated "Annotation" section. All my artboards have a text block below them in my design file where I write instructions for developers. This is time consuming because we have to copy/paste into InVision comments once we go to prototype. It would be the same process with Adobe XD. If we can do it in design mode, it's only 1 step, with much less room for error and way less headaches. If we separate out annotations and comments, that will make sure the annotations don't get lost. That could be as simple as using a separate color for annotations and pinning them to the top of the comment list.

  • Jake commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    Yes we need this and what Invision is doing with their studio

  • Reony Tonneyck commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    +1 for this, much needed! Currently if someone else opens the same file (since I share it with multiple designers), the same prototype link doesn't exist. Not sure how. Is it tied to the local machine? If they make a change, they cannot update the prototype themselves. Having comments embeded in a new view along with Design and Prototype, would be fantastic and ideal!

  • Pedro Gonçalves commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    After someone comments on the online prototype, send comments back to XD local file, or have an option to collect all comments from the online presentation, and pair the comments with the respective artboard.

  • Min commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    Voted for this.
    Need comments on unused artboards / comment history on artboards that later become unlinked.

  • Anonymous commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    It would be helpful to create comments in design or prototype mode.

    My front-end developers also use XD, and he (and I) would like to post comment in one file, because if we redesign some element, with share link we lost all comments.

    From Russia with Love.

Feedback and Knowledge Base